What do you get for that person on your list who, frankly, is impossible to shop for? They already have it all, or maybe you don’t know their tastes, and regifting a toaster oven just doesn’t feel right. In honor of all gifting enigmas, we put together this shop to satisfy the biggest question marks on your list—from your quirky step-dad to your new brother-in-law. Below you’ll find a bunch of unexpected gifts to please these nearly unpleasable people. Go ahead—hit ‘em with something that’ll knock their socks off.